Fixing Code Blocks: Removing \libglobal{}
Hey guys! Let's dive into a critical issue that's been bugging us: the \libglobal{} macro not being stripped from code blocks. This problem is making some of our files, specifically those containing critical library documentation, completely unusable. Sounds like a headache, right? Don't worry, we'll break it down, understand the impact, and figure out how to fix it. This is super important because it directly affects how we read, understand, and use our code examples. Let's get to it!
The Problem: Unstripped Macros in Code Blocks
Alright, so here's the deal. The \libglobal{} macro, which is supposed to mark globally visible library names, isn't being removed from our code blocks. Instead of just getting the identifier, we're seeing the entire \libglobal{identifier} text. This is a big no-no because it messes up the code formatting, making everything unreadable and, in many cases, completely breaking the code examples. Think of it like this: You expect a clean, easy-to-read snippet, but you get a messy, unusable block of text with extra fluff that doesn't belong there. This is especially problematic in files like meta.md, which is supposed to document type traits.
Where is the Problem Located?
The issue is widespread, popping up in multiple files. Let's pinpoint the affected areas:
-
meta.md: This file is hit the hardest, with a whopping 123 instances of the problem, particularly within the
<type_traits>and<ratio>synopsis sections. This makes the entire file practically useless.Example (line 271):
template
**Expected:**
```cpp
template<class T> struct is_void;
template<class T> struct is_null_pointer;
template<class T> struct is_integral;
-
diagnostics.md: Two instances of the issue.
Line 1249:
class \libglobal{stacktrace_entry} {
**Expected:**
```cpp
class stacktrace_entry {
**Line 1365:**
```cpp
class \libglobal{basic_stacktrace} {
**Expected:**
```cpp
class basic_stacktrace {
-
future.md: Two instances as well.
Line 1018:
using \libglobal{aligned_storage_t} = typename aligned_storage<Len, Align>::type;
**Expected:**
```cpp
using aligned_storage_t = typename aligned_storage<Len, Align>::type;
**Line 1022:**
```cpp
using \libglobal{aligned_union_t} = typename aligned_union<Len, Types...>::type;
**Expected:**
```cpp
using aligned_union_t = typename aligned_union<Len, Types...>::type;
A Deeper Look
We need to zero in on the precise location to effectively tackle this problem. The primary culprit is the cpp-code-blocks.lua filter. This filter is responsible for processing and cleaning up code blocks. It seems the filter isn't correctly handling the @\libglobal{...}@ escapes within these blocks. So, the essential task is to modify this filter to accurately strip the \libglobal{} macro while leaving the crucial identifier. The cpp-common.lua file, which contains various code cleaning utilities, might also be relevant in this process. Making the required edits in these files should resolve the issue.
Impact: What's at Stake?
So, what's the big deal? Why should we care about this macro issue? The impact is significant, affecting usability and the overall quality of our documentation. Here's a quick rundown:
- Severity: CRITICAL. This isn't just a minor cosmetic issue; it's a major roadblock.
- Unusable meta.md: The
meta.mdfile, which is crucial for documenting type traits, becomes completely unusable. The entire<type_traits>synopsis is filled with raw LaTeX macros, making it impossible to read or understand the code examples. - Non-compilable and unreadable code examples: The raw macros render the code examples incorrect and difficult to understand. This is a severe problem, especially for those who rely on these examples for practical learning or implementation.
- Affects critical library documentation: The core goal of our documentation—to clearly explain and illustrate key concepts and functions—is compromised.
- Complete conversion failure: Sections of the affected files fail to convert correctly, leading to major disruptions in the documentation process and final output.
Root Cause: Why is this Happening?
Here’s what's going on under the hood. The cpp-code-blocks.lua filter, which is supposed to clean up and format the code blocks, isn't processing the @\libglobal{...}@ escapes correctly. The filter should strip out the macro, leaving only the identifier. Instead, it's preserving the entire \libglobal{identifier} text. Think of it as a misplaced or ignored instruction in our code formatting process. The macro is used in LaTeX as: @\libglobal{identifier}@. The desired outcome is: identifier. The filter's job is to make this transformation, which it's currently failing to do.
How to Reproduce the Issue
Want to see the problem for yourself? Here’s a quick guide:
- Open
n4950/meta.md: Locate the file that's affected by this issue. - Navigate to lines 255-1279: This section is where the majority of the errors exist.
- Observe raw
\libglobal{...}macros: You'll see the unprocessed macros throughout the code examples. - Try to understand the type traits: Attempting to read or understand these type traits is almost impossible due to the unstripped macros.
Related Files: Where the Fix Lies
To solve this, we need to focus on a couple of key files:
src/cpp_std_converter/filters/cpp-code-blocks.lua: This file needs to be modified to correctly handle the@\libglobal{...}@pattern. The code block filter must be updated to strip the macro.src/cpp_std_converter/cpp-common.lua: While the main focus is on the code block filter, this file provides code cleaning utilities that might be helpful in the process.
Priority: Getting This Fixed
This is a CRITICAL issue, especially for meta.md. Because the file is broken, it's essentially unusable. This issue must be fixed before meta.md can be considered ready for production. This issue is a high-priority task, so let's get it resolved so we can get back to creating great content!
This issue significantly impacts our documentation's quality and usability, particularly for critical files like meta.md. Fixing this should be a top priority to ensure that our documentation is clear, accurate, and useful for everyone. Let's make sure this is fixed ASAP!