Ghost In The Shell (2017): A Deep Dive

Hey guys! Let's dive deep into the Ghost in the Shell (2017) movie. This film, a live-action adaptation of the acclaimed manga series by Masamune Shirow, has sparked quite a bit of conversation since its release. We’re going to explore what makes it tick, its strengths, its weaknesses, and why it remains a talking point among fans and critics alike. So, buckle up, and let's get started!

What is Ghost in the Shell?

Before we delve into the 2017 film, let's briefly touch on the Ghost in the Shell universe. Originally a manga, it follows Major Motoko Kusanagi, a cyborg employed by Public Security Section 9 in a futuristic Japan. The central themes revolve around identity, technology, and what it means to be human in a world increasingly dominated by cybernetics and artificial intelligence. The manga's success led to several anime adaptations, including the groundbreaking 1995 film directed by Mamoru Oshii, which is considered a cinematic masterpiece and heavily influenced subsequent science fiction works like The Matrix.

The core concept explores the philosophical implications of a 'ghost' (consciousness or soul) residing within a 'shell' (cybernetic body). This raises profound questions about individuality, memory, and the very nature of existence. As technology blurs the lines between human and machine, the characters grapple with their identities and purpose in a world where reality itself becomes malleable. This philosophical depth, combined with thrilling action and stunning visuals, is what has captivated audiences for decades and made Ghost in the Shell a cultural phenomenon.

The 2017 Adaptation: A Closer Look

The 2017 film adaptation, directed by Rupert Sanders and starring Scarlett Johansson as Major, aimed to bring this complex world to a broader audience. The movie follows Major as she grapples with her past and her identity while hunting a cyber-terrorist known as Kuze. Visually, the film is stunning, meticulously recreating iconic scenes and imagery from the anime. The neon-lit cityscapes, the advanced technology, and the overall aesthetic capture the essence of the Ghost in the Shell universe. However, the film faced criticism for its casting choices and perceived cultural appropriation, which we’ll discuss later.

While the visuals and action sequences were generally well-received, the narrative and character development received mixed reviews. Some viewers felt that the film simplified the complex philosophical themes of the original work, opting for a more straightforward action-oriented plot. Others argued that the film failed to fully explore Major's internal struggles and her quest for identity, which are central to the Ghost in the Shell narrative. Despite these criticisms, the film attempted to address some of the deeper themes, such as the nature of memory, the impact of technology on humanity, and the search for meaning in a technologically advanced world.

Visuals and Action: A Feast for the Eyes

One area where Ghost in the Shell (2017) truly shines is its visual presentation. The filmmakers went to great lengths to recreate the iconic imagery from the anime and manga, and the results are often breathtaking. The film is filled with stunning shots of the futuristic city, showcasing a vibrant blend of technology and urban decay. The use of holographic advertising, advanced robotics, and cybernetic enhancements creates a visually immersive world that feels both familiar and alien.

The action sequences are also a highlight, with Major showcasing her superhuman abilities in a series of thrilling set pieces. The fight choreography is well-executed, and the visual effects seamlessly blend with the practical stunts, creating a sense of realism and excitement. The film also incorporates elements of stealth and hacking, staying true to the cyberpunk roots of the franchise. Overall, the visual and action aspects of Ghost in the Shell (2017) are a testament to the filmmakers' dedication to bringing the world of Ghost in the Shell to life on the big screen.

Controversy and Casting

One of the biggest controversies surrounding Ghost in the Shell (2017) was the casting of Scarlett Johansson as Major. Many felt that casting a white actress in a role that was originally conceived as Japanese was an example of whitewashing and cultural appropriation. This sparked a widespread debate about representation in Hollywood and the importance of casting actors who reflect the ethnicity and cultural background of the characters they portray. The controversy overshadowed many other aspects of the film and undoubtedly impacted its reception.

Defenders of the casting choice argued that Major is a cyborg whose consciousness has been transferred into a synthetic body, making her ethnicity ambiguous. However, critics countered that the character's Japanese identity is an integral part of the Ghost in the Shell narrative and that casting a non-Asian actress erased that aspect of the story. The debate highlighted the complex issues surrounding race, representation, and cultural sensitivity in the entertainment industry. Ultimately, the controversy served as a reminder of the importance of diverse casting and the need for greater inclusivity in Hollywood.

Themes and Philosophical Depth

At its core, Ghost in the Shell explores profound philosophical themes about identity, consciousness, and the impact of technology on humanity. The 2017 film attempts to address these themes, but some viewers felt that it didn't delve as deeply as the original manga and anime. The film touches on the idea of what it means to be human in a world where the lines between human and machine are increasingly blurred. Major's struggle with her identity and her search for her past are central to the narrative, but some critics felt that these themes were not fully explored.

The film also examines the impact of technology on memory and reality. Major's memories are fragmented and unreliable, leading her to question her own existence and purpose. The film suggests that technology can be both a tool for empowerment and a source of manipulation, raising questions about the ethical implications of advanced cybernetics and artificial intelligence. While the 2017 film may not reach the same philosophical depth as the original Ghost in the Shell, it still offers some thought-provoking ideas about the nature of identity and the future of humanity.

Differences from the Original

There are several key differences between the 2017 film and the original Ghost in the Shell manga and anime. One of the most significant differences is the character of Major herself. In the original, Major is a complex and enigmatic figure, grappling with her own identity and questioning her purpose in a world dominated by technology. In the 2017 film, Major is portrayed as a more straightforward action hero, with less emphasis on her internal struggles.

The plot of the 2017 film also differs from the original in several ways. The film introduces a new villain, Kuze, who is not present in the original manga or anime. The film also simplifies some of the more complex plot points and philosophical themes, opting for a more streamlined narrative. While the 2017 film retains many of the iconic scenes and visual elements of the original, it ultimately tells a different story with a different focus. These changes were met with mixed reactions from fans, with some appreciating the new interpretation and others feeling that it strayed too far from the source material.

Reception and Impact

Ghost in the Shell (2017) received mixed reviews from critics and audiences alike. While the film was praised for its visuals and action sequences, it was criticized for its casting choices, perceived cultural appropriation, and simplification of the original's complex themes. The film's box office performance was also underwhelming, failing to recoup its substantial budget in the domestic market.

Despite its mixed reception, Ghost in the Shell (2017) has had a lasting impact on the science fiction genre. The film's stunning visuals and action sequences have influenced subsequent films and television shows, and its exploration of themes such as identity, technology, and the nature of reality continues to resonate with audiences. The controversy surrounding the film's casting also sparked important conversations about representation and cultural sensitivity in Hollywood. Ultimately, Ghost in the Shell (2017) serves as a reminder of the challenges and opportunities involved in adapting beloved source material for a new audience.

Final Thoughts

So, where does Ghost in the Shell (2017) stand? It’s a visually impressive film that attempts to capture the essence of a complex and beloved franchise. While it may not reach the same philosophical depths as the original manga and anime, it offers a thrilling action experience and raises some thought-provoking questions about the future of humanity. Whether you love it or hate it, Ghost in the Shell (2017) is a film that sparks conversation and invites us to consider the implications of technology on our lives and our identities. What do you guys think? Let me know in the comments below!